63 Comments
User's avatar
jukk0u's avatar

The states bordering Methico and the ones suffering the domestic terrorist sponsored importation of "migrants" are becoming painfully aware of the States' sovereignty rights lost in the War of Northern aggression.

Kitsune, Maskless Crusader.'s avatar

One key difference between the two men discussed here is that the earlier one did this BEFORE an act of war was committed and the later on AFTER an act of war.

In his memoirs, Grant brought up another point. The land inhabited by the secessionist was purchased from the national treasury with funds from the entire country for the better of the entire country.

Courageous Lion's avatar

The act of "war" was a provocation by the North. Ft Sumpter was a SOUTHERN fort. They took it over (an act of war) and the south attacked it to get them out. Oh, you never heard that before? Well golly gee, I'm shocked.

Kitsune, Maskless Crusader.'s avatar

What? It was a national fort built with federal funds and garrisoned by the US army before succession. The first shots in anger were against a supply vessel bringing food and probably munitions for the garrison of the fort.

Courageous Lion's avatar

You believe the propaganda that you believe and I'll believe the propaganda I'll believe. Because you know what? NEITHER of us know the actual truth unless we would have been there. We have to go by hearsay written by the side that won. I read from the side that lost. So we have two conflicting views. Are you SURPRISED?

The SOUTH was RIGHT. PERIOD. It wasn't over slavery. Because if it was, you wouldn't be a SLAVE right now. Nor would I.

Kitsune, Maskless Crusader.'s avatar

We are enslaved right now because a few Governors of southern states were too big for their britches and used the State’s Rights issue as a defense of a State’s right to enslave human beings. Their argument on States’ rights is sound, but they choose the absolutely worst “right” to go to war over.

That got almost every thing they wanted from the North in regards to slavery. They got to count slaves toward the population of southern districts for representation; that is huge. They got to continue breeding slaves and selling them. They received property rights protection of their slaves if they traveled to a free state with their slaves. And, they got passed into law the Fujitive Slave Act requiring escaped slaved who made it to a free state to be returned to them and made it a federal crime to aid escaped slaves. The one thing they did not get with slavery that they wanted was to be able to continue importing slaves. Hell, these southerners even started the Mexican American war in hopes of expanding slave holding territory in the country and increase their power in the federal legislature.

And with these complaints and concessions the South remained in the union until Lincoln, whom they perceived to be an abolitionist was elected. They did not go to war over taxes, nor tariffs, the really big issue other than slavery, they went to war over the belief that Lincoln would abolish slavery.

We don’t know? Read the writings of the gentleman of the south at this time, their speeches, their news papers. They state very different sentiments than you claim they held. To be fair, they changed their tune as the war drug on and especially after. But read what they were saying leading up to and immediately after Lincoln’s election.

Kitsune, Maskless Crusader.'s avatar

Dude, the American Civil War is the top is I have studied the most. My personal library on the war contains over 150 books. It’s not propaganda I wrote, it’s history. The Federal government did not take over the fort over. It was the property of the federal government.

On what the war was over. You are correct in that there were many long standing issues, taxes being one, in which the South had been vocally opposed to. But it was not until a president from a new party that formed, at least in part, for the purpose of needing slavery that the South finally decided to part company. The tinder had long been laid, but it was the slavery issue that lit it.

Nina's avatar

I am always dismayed when I see a survey of supposedly educated citizens and they rank the despicable Lincoln as the #1 or #2 best President. He is at the very bottom of my list.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Feb 24, 2024Edited
Comment removed
Kitsune, Maskless Crusader.'s avatar

on’t let this gross misrepresentation of what happened leading up to, during and after the civil war to change your impression of President Lincoln. Yes, it is true that he suspended the writ of habeas corpus, but it was not national wide. The suspension was in Washington D.C. and the surrounding area, which was a hot bed of secessionist agitation and activity. The important thing to know about this is that those who by word or by action claimed to longer be under the rule of federal law then cry when they are not also under its protection.

Courageous Lion's avatar

I hate to pop your bubble on Father Abraham, actually I don't hate to.

Most Americans consider Abraham Lincoln to be the greatest president in history. His legend as the Great Emancipator has grown to mythic proportions as hundreds of books, a national holiday, and a monument in Washington, D.C., extol his heroism and martyrdom. But what if most everything you knew about Lincoln were false? What if, instead of an American hero who sought to free the slaves, Lincoln were in fact a calculating politician who waged the bloodiest war in American history in order to build an empire that rivaled Great Britain's?

In The Real Lincoln, author Thomas J. DiLorenzo uncovers a side of Lincoln not told in many history books--and overshadowed by the immense Lincoln legend. Through extensive research and meticulous documentation, DiLorenzo portrays the sixteenth president as a man who devoted his political career to revolutionizing the American form of government from one that was very limited in scope and highly decentralized—as the Founding Fathers intended—to a highly centralized, activist state. Standing in his way, however, was the South, with its independent states, its resistance to the national government, and its reliance on unfettered free trade. To accomplish his goals, Lincoln subverted the Constitution, trampled states' rights, and launched a devastating Civil War, whose wounds haunt us still. According to this provocative book, 600,000 American soldiers did not die for the honorable cause of ending slavery but for the dubious agenda of sacrificing the independence of the states to the supremacy of the federal government, which has been tightening its vise grip on our republic to this very day.

In The Real Lincoln, you will discover a side of Lincoln that you were probably never taught in school—a side that calls into question the very myths that surround him and helps explain the true origins of a bloody, and perhaps, unnecessary war.

https://www.amazon.com/Real-Lincoln-Abraham-Agenda-Unnecessary/dp/0761526463

Kitsune, Maskless Crusader.'s avatar

In “Four Years with the Iron Brigade: The Civil War Journals of William R Ray, Co. F, Seventh Wisconsin Infantry”, the author tells of a confederate POW who shared a tent with him in a military hospital and became his “particular friend”. At one point, Ray asked his johnny friend, why he was fighting. The answer, of course, “My rights.” He then asked for this confederate soldier to explain which of his rights were at risk. No answer, silence.

Beyond tariffs which the ordinary person in the south had nothing to do with, what other “rights” did Lincoln threaten? The only right I can name, is the “right” to keep another human as property.

Kitsune, Maskless Crusader.'s avatar

And yet, none of that would have happened, not at that time and place as it did, had not the south first fired upon Fort Sumter, a federal fort garrisoned by the US army before hand.

You remove any except one of the issues that led to the civil war and there is still a civil war. If the tariff system was changed so that the south was made happy, still a war. If the south were allowed to import new slaves, still a war. Protect slavery, no war. The way of life they fought to protect had slavery woven into its fabric.

This argument net about subverting the constitution needs greater discussion. What actions did Lincoln under take in the 6 weeks between his inauguration and the firing upon Fort Sumter? These subversions to the constitution were against those who openly sated they were not held to the laws of the United States. For them to then cry foul when they are not protected by the laws they disavow is just plain childish.

Courageous Lion's avatar

At the risk of being redundant...

I hate to pop your bubble on Father Abraham, actually I don't hate to.

Most Americans consider Abraham Lincoln to be the greatest president in history. His legend as the Great Emancipator has grown to mythic proportions as hundreds of books, a national holiday, and a monument in Washington, D.C., extol his heroism and martyrdom. But what if most everything you knew about Lincoln were false? What if, instead of an American hero who sought to free the slaves, Lincoln were in fact a calculating politician who waged the bloodiest war in American history in order to build an empire that rivaled Great Britain's?

In The Real Lincoln, author Thomas J. DiLorenzo uncovers a side of Lincoln not told in many history books--and overshadowed by the immense Lincoln legend. Through extensive research and meticulous documentation, DiLorenzo portrays the sixteenth president as a man who devoted his political career to revolutionizing the American form of government from one that was very limited in scope and highly decentralized—as the Founding Fathers intended—to a highly centralized, activist state. Standing in his way, however, was the South, with its independent states, its resistance to the national government, and its reliance on unfettered free trade. To accomplish his goals, Lincoln subverted the Constitution, trampled states' rights, and launched a devastating Civil War, whose wounds haunt us still. According to this provocative book, 600,000 American soldiers did not die for the honorable cause of ending slavery but for the dubious agenda of sacrificing the independence of the states to the supremacy of the federal government, which has been tightening its vise grip on our republic to this very day.

In The Real Lincoln, you will discover a side of Lincoln that you were probably never taught in school—a side that calls into question the very myths that surround him and helps explain the true origins of a bloody, and perhaps, unnecessary war.

https://www.amazon.com/Real-Lincoln-Abraham-Agenda-Unnecessary/dp/0761526463

User's avatar
Comment removed
Feb 26, 2024
Comment removed
Courageous Lion's avatar

There is no why. It is a RIGHT and to suspend it is an INFRINGEMENT. Something "father" Abraham was quite adept at doing. The whole idea that a group of people who form a "state" can leave a compact when the compact is broken is hogwash. Lincoln was the first (of many) dictators who went way past his office of president with executive orders and his desire to do away with the sovereignty of the states is quite obvious. Well unless you're a Maskless Crusader.

Kitsune, Maskless Crusader.'s avatar

Yes, it does, but so is having the Capital sacked or at least completely cut off. Washington DC was surrounded by southern states. A regiment of New York volunteer infantry was attacked by an angry mob as they marched between train stations on their way to defend the capital. Wars are not pleasant. Best not to invite them.

Courageous Lion's avatar

And of course the south invited it. Trying to get you to see the other side of the story is fruitless. You must think that what came out of the war, which was Lincolns aim when it came to a federal government with 435 agencies and tyrannical acts from the day the war ended is a wonderful way to run things. Be happy with your chains.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Feb 26, 2024
Comment removed