Well written and reasoned piece, though not without a hedge. Margaret Thatcher once famously questioned the existence of "society" and posited only individuals and families as the most fundamental organizing principle of humanity.
I am the polar opposite of Thatcherism (socialism for the rich, austerity for the rest of us), and though I agree that "society" is an abstract, emergent epiphenomenon ... I question the status of 'individual' as the fundamental ground of a social primate, and prefer families and small communities as a more defensible position for our default of organization.
Here in Japan, for example, there was no Japanese word for individual until a translation of Jean-Jacques Rousseau required a new word ... "koujin". Prior to that coinage, individuals were not invisible, but they were defined in terms of relationships. Even now, there is no Japanese word for "brother" or "sister". It is either "older" or "younger" brother or sister.
Certainly individual autonomy is necessary for biological survival at the most basic level, but for a social primate prior to the evolution of transportation and larger heterogenous populations, banishment was pretty close to the death sentence among all cultures.
Meh, it may just boil down to the limits of language and logic in defining 'individual' outside of a social context. After all, I do believe that individual choice (moral autonomy), even if it means sacrificing one's self for the good of the marginalized 'other' (e.g. a mother for her new-born, a father for his family, etc.) is paramount.
I was glad to see the importance of social context, with a small "s", weighed heavily on the minds of the founding fathers.
I read it years ago and recently came upon it again and felt the information was good enough to share to as many as possible. Thanks for taking your time to do so and for your thoughtful comment. I don't see too much in common with the Asian culture vs the Saxon one that I'm a member of. Ordinarily they seem to me, to have more of a bee hive mentality where as the Saxons have always had a more independent spirit as a whole. But all societies seem to have a flaw in allowing those among them to take leadership positions that are actually psychopathic control freaks. Just look at some of the insanity that has been coming out with people like Kathy Hotchul in New York and Jacinda Ardern from New Zealand. Total raving lunatics.
Was just going through posts and came across this. Totally agree with you about how Cluster B / Dark Tetrad temperaments tend to make, and then game their Tower of Babel game of thrones.
Just wanted to mention that depending on domain and point of view ... the beehive mentality thing is universal, a somewhat de-individualizing point of view, and in war-time scenarios, a very real social phenomenon. For example, Japanese are quite varied and independent in what we ordinarily think of as the religious domain ... and when they look at most of the Judeo-Christian-Muslim world and religious wars ... they think "bee hive mentality" of the West. Regarding the institutionalized aspect of most organized religion, I tend to agree.
But as I said, during times of external threat and the propagandizing from the sociopaths in control, Japanese also go into kamikaze beehive mode. Just like the 300 Spartans.
Meh. We are all social primates, some just a bit pathologically warped than others.
I honestly think it's technology. People can't even drive down the road without it. Weird all far left people are constantly praised and those opposed are ridiculed in a way that in my day would have had to occur face to face and they'd got their teeth rearranged! Social media has done nothing but cultivate a very unhealthy environment! I miss zero about fascistbook and on here, Gab, Clouthub, Locals, etc I flat don't engage with brutal attackers or people making completely off the wall comments. Mute and block...move along. Like the rest of the websites I'm on I'm only there for like minded conversations that are actually beneficial. If people want to vote democratic or keep getting the clot shot while still wearing mask and gloves more power to them. Litterally not our problem anymore. It's like Christianity...it's reached all four corners of the world, as Bible instructed, and it's on them if they don't believe. They can't blame crooked churches or pastors because the Bible is specific about free will and not putting your faith in man. I do agree with genetic defect when it comes to LGBQT. To me it's like Schizophrenia, etc...they can still function, have jobs, relationships, but something went wrong. It also doesn't help we have parents coddling their children and letting them dress however or act like a furrie. Allowing them day and night on technology. They are more than likely perfectly normal being influenced in the worst way during the most vulnerable years of their mental growth. Walk into any restaurant...mom, dad, and two children ALL staring at their technology not engaging. It's sad. Then let's add schools FORCING children to learn about everything other than reading, writing, and arithmetic. They have to go along with every whackadoodle ideology or face being ridiculed and reprimanded! It's honestly an insult to a person's intelligence to be forced to call a boy a girl, vice-versa, or that being a furrie is cool! I know what I see. I'll add that doesn't mean I approve of people bullying or making fun of a person for anything, but that's EXACTLY what they are doing to us! Agree or not only get verbally abused, but possibly physically! That's complete crap! Because they, antifia, blm, liberals act like rabid animals and police, judicial system, government, etc do NOTHING about it we continue to feel obligated to remain silent except on social media... Vicious cycle unfortunately.
I am in an on-again / off again running debate with friends on substack who insist that we not label such people, but rather, focus on the behavior .... that "love the evil doer, not the evil thingy". I see their point in trying to avoid falling into the fundamental attribution fallacy. But they tend to take it a step further and insist that all deviant behavior can be traced back to childhood trauma, and therefore are capable of being treated by counseling intervention or "saved" by the power of religion.
I have my doubts, and having come across people who I know that no amount of counseling will change. Research also shows a strong genetic component. James Fallon's book, "The Psychopath Inside" is a good read.
Also, I recently came upon a good podcast (can't remember the link), but the specialist said that there is now a rough agreement that counseling is not a recommended treatment for true (morphologically defined) psychopaths. Why? Because they are wired differently, wired in such a way as to see counseling techniques as another weapon to add to their arsenal.
If it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck, and flies like a duck ... it just might be a pig ... though that would be a disservice to good pigs. 😂
"Alexis de Tocqueville came to America in the 1830s. He was astonished that 'government was more or less invisible.'”
Paine knew from experience that government is not necessary.
"For upwards of two years from the commencement of the American War, and to a longer period in several of the American States, there were no established forms of government. The old governments had been abolished, and the country was too much occupied in defence to employ its attention in establishing new governments; yet during this interval order and harmony were preserved as inviolate as in any country in Europe.
"The more perfect civilisation is, the less occasion has it for government, because the more does it regulate its own affairs, and govern itself...
Thomas Paine, "Chapter I. Of Society and Civilisation", The Rights of Man (1791)
These are the lessons in history that the psychopathic control freak PARASITES do not want us to know about. Is this all from the Rights of Man? IT PROVES ANARCHY WORKS. The FUCKERS in charge due to the majority of man kinds IGNORANCE do NOT want us to know that it works. NO RULERS...and the rules are simple...DO NO HARM.
Yes. Since the first kings emerged in Sumer about 7,000 years ago, the government controllists have gone to great lengths to convince us that they are necessary, that without rule by government there will be chaos.
It has always been a lie. The controllers are merely parasites. They serve no purpose; they only DO HARM.
Note to my husband after an unjust accusation of being "radicalised Far-Right" was flung at me.
9/11/23
Self-sovereignty knows no politics. It leans neither left nor right. It is centred upon individual conscience which supercedes all external "authority". It is the inalienable right of every human, not a privilege given by government. It is not removed just because of the latest manufactured "emergency".
I am as I have always been. I think as I have always thought. I have not changed. I have never, nor will I ever give consent to the horror and incompetence that is the governance of this world. As an empath, my heart and soul bleed for the billions of victims of that governance.
"The ultimate tyranny in a society is not control by martial law. It is control by the psychological manipulation of consciousness, through which reality is defined so that those who exist within it do not even realize that they are in prison."
WHAT? Your husband said that to you? I guess he is wearing the panties in your house? Geezzzz...I can't even imagine saying something like that to my wife. EVER. UNALIENABLE means "Unalienable: incapable of being alienated, that is, sold and transferred." Black's Law Dictionary, Sixth Edition, page 1523:
You can not surrender, sell or transfer unalienable rights, they are a gift from the creator to the individual and can not under any circumstances be surrendered or taken. All individual's have unalienable rights. They can only be INFRINGED upon. You are what I'd like every man that is married to have for a wife when it comes to your understanding. YOU KEEP GOING WOMAN!!!
Well written and reasoned piece, though not without a hedge. Margaret Thatcher once famously questioned the existence of "society" and posited only individuals and families as the most fundamental organizing principle of humanity.
I am the polar opposite of Thatcherism (socialism for the rich, austerity for the rest of us), and though I agree that "society" is an abstract, emergent epiphenomenon ... I question the status of 'individual' as the fundamental ground of a social primate, and prefer families and small communities as a more defensible position for our default of organization.
Here in Japan, for example, there was no Japanese word for individual until a translation of Jean-Jacques Rousseau required a new word ... "koujin". Prior to that coinage, individuals were not invisible, but they were defined in terms of relationships. Even now, there is no Japanese word for "brother" or "sister". It is either "older" or "younger" brother or sister.
Certainly individual autonomy is necessary for biological survival at the most basic level, but for a social primate prior to the evolution of transportation and larger heterogenous populations, banishment was pretty close to the death sentence among all cultures.
Meh, it may just boil down to the limits of language and logic in defining 'individual' outside of a social context. After all, I do believe that individual choice (moral autonomy), even if it means sacrificing one's self for the good of the marginalized 'other' (e.g. a mother for her new-born, a father for his family, etc.) is paramount.
I was glad to see the importance of social context, with a small "s", weighed heavily on the minds of the founding fathers.
Good post!
I read it years ago and recently came upon it again and felt the information was good enough to share to as many as possible. Thanks for taking your time to do so and for your thoughtful comment. I don't see too much in common with the Asian culture vs the Saxon one that I'm a member of. Ordinarily they seem to me, to have more of a bee hive mentality where as the Saxons have always had a more independent spirit as a whole. But all societies seem to have a flaw in allowing those among them to take leadership positions that are actually psychopathic control freaks. Just look at some of the insanity that has been coming out with people like Kathy Hotchul in New York and Jacinda Ardern from New Zealand. Total raving lunatics.
They see demon possessed……
Hotchul and Arden are demon possessed along with the others, and I now really believe that
Hi C.L.
Was just going through posts and came across this. Totally agree with you about how Cluster B / Dark Tetrad temperaments tend to make, and then game their Tower of Babel game of thrones.
Just wanted to mention that depending on domain and point of view ... the beehive mentality thing is universal, a somewhat de-individualizing point of view, and in war-time scenarios, a very real social phenomenon. For example, Japanese are quite varied and independent in what we ordinarily think of as the religious domain ... and when they look at most of the Judeo-Christian-Muslim world and religious wars ... they think "bee hive mentality" of the West. Regarding the institutionalized aspect of most organized religion, I tend to agree.
But as I said, during times of external threat and the propagandizing from the sociopaths in control, Japanese also go into kamikaze beehive mode. Just like the 300 Spartans.
Meh. We are all social primates, some just a bit pathologically warped than others.
Cheers from Japan C.L.
Keep up the good fight.
Some are a LOT more pathologically warped. It appears they may have a genetic defect.
I honestly think it's technology. People can't even drive down the road without it. Weird all far left people are constantly praised and those opposed are ridiculed in a way that in my day would have had to occur face to face and they'd got their teeth rearranged! Social media has done nothing but cultivate a very unhealthy environment! I miss zero about fascistbook and on here, Gab, Clouthub, Locals, etc I flat don't engage with brutal attackers or people making completely off the wall comments. Mute and block...move along. Like the rest of the websites I'm on I'm only there for like minded conversations that are actually beneficial. If people want to vote democratic or keep getting the clot shot while still wearing mask and gloves more power to them. Litterally not our problem anymore. It's like Christianity...it's reached all four corners of the world, as Bible instructed, and it's on them if they don't believe. They can't blame crooked churches or pastors because the Bible is specific about free will and not putting your faith in man. I do agree with genetic defect when it comes to LGBQT. To me it's like Schizophrenia, etc...they can still function, have jobs, relationships, but something went wrong. It also doesn't help we have parents coddling their children and letting them dress however or act like a furrie. Allowing them day and night on technology. They are more than likely perfectly normal being influenced in the worst way during the most vulnerable years of their mental growth. Walk into any restaurant...mom, dad, and two children ALL staring at their technology not engaging. It's sad. Then let's add schools FORCING children to learn about everything other than reading, writing, and arithmetic. They have to go along with every whackadoodle ideology or face being ridiculed and reprimanded! It's honestly an insult to a person's intelligence to be forced to call a boy a girl, vice-versa, or that being a furrie is cool! I know what I see. I'll add that doesn't mean I approve of people bullying or making fun of a person for anything, but that's EXACTLY what they are doing to us! Agree or not only get verbally abused, but possibly physically! That's complete crap! Because they, antifia, blm, liberals act like rabid animals and police, judicial system, government, etc do NOTHING about it we continue to feel obligated to remain silent except on social media... Vicious cycle unfortunately.
Indeed CL!
I am in an on-again / off again running debate with friends on substack who insist that we not label such people, but rather, focus on the behavior .... that "love the evil doer, not the evil thingy". I see their point in trying to avoid falling into the fundamental attribution fallacy. But they tend to take it a step further and insist that all deviant behavior can be traced back to childhood trauma, and therefore are capable of being treated by counseling intervention or "saved" by the power of religion.
I have my doubts, and having come across people who I know that no amount of counseling will change. Research also shows a strong genetic component. James Fallon's book, "The Psychopath Inside" is a good read.
Also, I recently came upon a good podcast (can't remember the link), but the specialist said that there is now a rough agreement that counseling is not a recommended treatment for true (morphologically defined) psychopaths. Why? Because they are wired differently, wired in such a way as to see counseling techniques as another weapon to add to their arsenal.
If it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck, and flies like a duck ... it just might be a pig ... though that would be a disservice to good pigs. 😂
Cheers C.L.!
"Alexis de Tocqueville came to America in the 1830s. He was astonished that 'government was more or less invisible.'”
Paine knew from experience that government is not necessary.
"For upwards of two years from the commencement of the American War, and to a longer period in several of the American States, there were no established forms of government. The old governments had been abolished, and the country was too much occupied in defence to employ its attention in establishing new governments; yet during this interval order and harmony were preserved as inviolate as in any country in Europe.
"The more perfect civilisation is, the less occasion has it for government, because the more does it regulate its own affairs, and govern itself...
Thomas Paine, "Chapter I. Of Society and Civilisation", The Rights of Man (1791)
These are the lessons in history that the psychopathic control freak PARASITES do not want us to know about. Is this all from the Rights of Man? IT PROVES ANARCHY WORKS. The FUCKERS in charge due to the majority of man kinds IGNORANCE do NOT want us to know that it works. NO RULERS...and the rules are simple...DO NO HARM.
Yes. Since the first kings emerged in Sumer about 7,000 years ago, the government controllists have gone to great lengths to convince us that they are necessary, that without rule by government there will be chaos.
It has always been a lie. The controllers are merely parasites. They serve no purpose; they only DO HARM.
Note to my husband after an unjust accusation of being "radicalised Far-Right" was flung at me.
9/11/23
Self-sovereignty knows no politics. It leans neither left nor right. It is centred upon individual conscience which supercedes all external "authority". It is the inalienable right of every human, not a privilege given by government. It is not removed just because of the latest manufactured "emergency".
I am as I have always been. I think as I have always thought. I have not changed. I have never, nor will I ever give consent to the horror and incompetence that is the governance of this world. As an empath, my heart and soul bleed for the billions of victims of that governance.
"The ultimate tyranny in a society is not control by martial law. It is control by the psychological manipulation of consciousness, through which reality is defined so that those who exist within it do not even realize that they are in prison."
Teachings from the Pleiadians
WHAT? Your husband said that to you? I guess he is wearing the panties in your house? Geezzzz...I can't even imagine saying something like that to my wife. EVER. UNALIENABLE means "Unalienable: incapable of being alienated, that is, sold and transferred." Black's Law Dictionary, Sixth Edition, page 1523:
You can not surrender, sell or transfer unalienable rights, they are a gift from the creator to the individual and can not under any circumstances be surrendered or taken. All individual's have unalienable rights. They can only be INFRINGED upon. You are what I'd like every man that is married to have for a wife when it comes to your understanding. YOU KEEP GOING WOMAN!!!
My roar may not be loud, but it is profound.